The Vaccination Decision: Vaccines and Autism
Once again this week we are talking about vaccination. So far, we’ve covered the pros and some of the cons. But the biggest con by far, the potential link between vaccines and autism, warranted a blog post all on its own.
The sheer amount of news stories, studies, interviews, and papers released on this topic to date is nothing short of mind-numbing. As is the amount of finger-pointing, contradictions, and paranoia that exists on both sides of the debate. For every study that you find that either proves or disproves the connection between vaccines and autism, you will find a laundry list of concerns regarding the way the studies were set up and who funded them.
Complicating the issue further is the possibility that, the link between autism and vaccines (if there is one) may not be clear cut. Its entirely possible that vaccines may trigger autism in children who are “genetically susceptible” to the disease. Its also possible that it is not any one vaccine (or vaccine component) that can be linked to autism, but rather the fact that so many vaccines are given in so short a time, that may cause trigger the onset of autism.
In other words, regardless of your stance on the vaccine/autism issue, there is no shortage of information to support and/or refute your claim. Here are some links where you can find more details about vaccines and autism.
Pro-Vaccine: There is no link between vaccines and autism
- : “The weight of the evidence indicates that vaccines are not associated with autism.”
- :”there is no scientifically proven link between measles vaccination and autism.”
- Dr. Paul Ofitt, Director, Vaccine Education Center, Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia: “Studies of 1) the genetics of autism, 2) the timing of the first symptoms of autism (home-movie studies), 3) the relationship between autism and the receipt of the MMR vaccine, 4) the histopathology of the central nervous system of children with autism, and 5) thalidomide, natural rubella infection, fragile X syndrome, and tuberous sclerosis all support the fact that autism occurs during development of the central nervous system early in utero.” (From )
- : “There is no link between autism and the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) vaccine or the vaccine preservative thimerosal, according to a report released by the Institute of Medicine’s (IOM) .”
- : To date there is no definite, scientific proof that any vaccine or combination of vaccines can cause autism.”
Anti-Vaccine: There is a strong link between vaccines and autism
- (Kids Need Options With Vaccines): “The strong correlation between autism and vaccine history becomes even more credible when the disease characteristics for both autism and mercury poisoning are compared.”
- Autism Research Institute: List of studies linking thimerosal and/or the MMR vaccine to autism: and
- : 2005 book identifies a possible link between thimerosal and rising rates of autism.
- : Jenny McCarthy’s organization that researches the causes and treatments for autism.
- : The blog of Ginger Taylor, and “autism mom” who writes about “news and commentary on the autism epidemic and my beautiful boy who is living with autism.”
Is your head spinning yet? Now consider these two recent headlines in the vaccine/autism debate:
March 2008: The Department of Health and Human Services’ Division of Vaccine Injury Compensation concluded that in the case of (an eight year girl whose parents believe her autism was caused by vaccines,) an underlying illness that had predisposed her to symptoms of autism was “significantly aggravated” by the vaccinations she received as a toddler and that her family should therefore be compensated.
Feburay 1, 2009: A new study published in the journal, Clinical Infectious Diseases, finds “there is no correlation between vaccines and autism.”
And so we’re back to square one.
Photo: “Artism: art for Autism” by .
/images/ads/120.jpg)
This is a very, very heated (and diffuclt) debate. Both of my children are on the autism spectrum and so for the past 2.5 years, I’ve read everything I can get my hands on about the vaccine/autism debate. I know that a lot of people are wanting to differentiate between autistic-like symptoms that arise from heavy metal/mercury poisoning and “true autism” which is difficult to do.
I know of mommas who have never vaccinated their child, have never been vaccinated themselves and had intervention and drug free pregnancies/homebirths but still have a child with autism. I also know other mommas who have had their child regress significantly after receiving vaccines so as you said at the end, we’re back to square one.
In the case of my kiddos, my vote goes for a genetic predisposition to autism/Asperger’s syndrome.
Well actually there is no genetic cause. A genetic cause to autism was searched for and not found. Even more interesting is that with identical twins, one may have severe autism and the other twin may be perfectly normal. Meaning that conditions in the womb and genetics cannot account for autism. Although it is possible that vaccines could turn on a autism gene or turn off another gene that helps to regulate how the body functions in numerous ways. Viruses can cause this gene regulation. So can hormones and numerous other environmental factors. So vaccines could cause autism in one child and a child whose mom consumed too much tuna during pregnancy could cause another child to be autistic. Or the strain of the virus in the vaccines itself could cause this neurological damage as seen in the past with certain flu epidemics where people exposed became catatonic.
However the last study mentioned did not find autism was not caused by vaccines or a series of vaccines. It simply found that earlier data showing the MMR vaccine virus strain in the digestive systems of autistic children was inaccurate. That is far from proving that autism is not caused by or made worse by vaccines.
I hope you will cover the latest from the UK:
Andrew Wakefield, the UK physician who first claimed a connection between the MMR vaccine and autism, fabricated most of his data.
The most in-depth review is at Science-Based Medicine.
http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=370
Antivaccine hero Andrew Wakefield: Scientific fraud?
Published by David Gorski under Science and the Media, Vaccines
Comments: 11
Pity poor Andrew Wakefield.
Actually, on second thought, Wakefield deserves no pity at all. After all, he is the man who almost single-handedly launched the scare over the MMR vaccine in Britain when he published his infamous Lancet paper in 1998 in which he claimed to have linked the MMR vaccine to regressive autism and inflammation of the colon, a study that was followed up four years later with a paper that claimed to have found the strain of attenuated measles virus in the MMR in the colons of autistic children by polymerase chain reaction (PCR). It would be one thing if these studies were sound science. If that were the case, then Wakefield’s work would have been very important and would have correctly cast doubt on the safety of the MMR. Unfortunately, they were not, and, indeed, most of the authors of the 1998 Lancet paper later withdrew their names from it.
I’ve done another round-up post — who is saying what about the Deer articles on Wakefield in the London Times.
11 years on, Wakefield Manufactured Data showing MMR-Autism Link?
I have a dear friend from my husband’s family practice residency days with two autistic children…and he vaccinates kids! That speaks very loudly to me!!!
I just read a study done by the IATP that states there is mercury in high fructose corn syrup.
Could this be a cause of rising autism? Isn’t that why some people say that vaccines cause autism? Because of the mercury? I don’t know if mercury will cause autism but here is some more information on the study I found: http://blog.calorie-help.com/2009/02/09/high-fructose-corn-syrup-andautism/
And so we’re back to square one.
Are you kidding? I hope to god you’re kidding.
Look at who is on the “there’s no link side” – the CDC; the American Academy of Pediatrics; an academic pediatrician vaccine specialist at the best pediatrics hospital in the country; the FDA; and the NIH.
On the other side: a northern Florida non-profit run by a Toni Krehel, AP; the Autism Research Institute; a non-peer reviewed book; Jenny McCarthy and her organization; and a personal blog by a non-scientist.
On one side, that is, you have the entirety of all the opinions of all mainstream science and medicine in this country; and on the other you have a couple of people, half of whom have no training or credentials of any kind.
If you are truly going to throw up your hands and say, well, there’s no way of knowing, then you should stop blogging on this subject entirely. There is NO CONTROVERSY HERE: and you are hurting people by pretending that there is one.
If you read mainstream medicine’s “Bible” – the Merck Manual, you will learn that the vast majority of diseases have no known cause. When you have no cause, all you have left is treatment. Treatments make more money than finding the cause. Mainstream medicine does not want to find the cause of autism especially if it related to vaccines or antibiotics. Isn’t it interesting that we can send men into space, send minute cameras into the body, look at live blood, but we have no idea what causes autism, allergies, ADHD, or asthma? There is big money to make treating people for life. Medicine has become BIG business instead of about really healing people. It is only a grassroots movement that will find the cause or cure for most diseases. So, yes, I will definitely listen to “a couple of people, half of whom have no training or credentials”, before I will listen to the FDA, CDC, Academy of Pediatrics, or NIH – because the credentials mean they only think within the allowed box of mainstream medicine.
Autism is a life long disorder. There is also an epidemic of children misdiagnosed with autism who really have things like “fetal alcohol syndrome” or “fragile x” or “laundau kleffner syndrome (Jenny mccarthy’s son), “adhd” or “aspergers” or “PDD” that aren’t truly autistic, so it’s important to separate the non-autistics with the truly autistics, or we will FOREVER be spinning in a cirlce of confusion when it comes to research and treatment of authentic true autism. See cdfoakley channel on youtube for a look at what is probably the most authentic look at true SEVERE autsim seen on internet. Of course, there are other higher functioning autistics, but this channel gives researchers an insight into what severe to PROFOUND autism looks like. Very important. Extremely educational. And don’t forget cases like Donna Williams, the alleged “high functioning autistic” who for years wrote books about her HF autism, but now has recently been diagnosed with multiple personality disorder or Dissociative Identity Disorder Google: “blog.donnawilliams.net/…/losing-time-dissociative-identity-disorder-and-the-real-time-travellers” We have to be very CAREFUL who we call autistic and who we call other things, because it seems AUTISM has become a very popular label assigned to NON autistics, which actually HURTS the truly autistic population. Be careful. Know what autism is, and what it is NOT. Jenny McCarthy’s son was said to NEVER have had autism, but Landau Kleffner Syndrome. So be careful. As for John Travolta’s son, Jett, he was TRULY autistic and the public didn’t understand the PAIN or pressure this poor man and his family endured while trying to raise this child. This is WHY it is critical TRUE autism, especially autism with epilepsy is understood by PUBLIC. And as for autistics who suffer from constant self abuse, take a look at kgaccount or cdfoakly on YOU TUBE for a REAL look on autism and self injurious behavior. Be prepared to have your eyes opened.
Very heloful information. Would you mind if I quoted parts of this page if I provided a link back here and cited you as the source? Thanks
To many of us, it was a well thought-out plan: with more money, there comes security; then it would be time to have kids..
I’m truly enjoying the design and layout of your blog. It’s a very easy on the eyes which makes it much more enjoyable for me to come here and visit more often. Did you hire out a developer to create your theme? Outstanding work!
Hello! I just stump upon your page via Google. What a informative blog you have! I like it very much! Now you got this fantastic blog, why not turn it into income? Thank you for putting out such precious information to the entire internet landscape!
Hello, was yesterday good for you? I enjoyed your site, keep up the great work.
ルイヴィトンコピー ルイヴィトンスーパーコピールイヴィトンコピー ルイヴィトンスーパーコピー http://www.vuittoncopy.com
Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts. Any way I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.
What would happen if someone posted a false pic of miley cyrus naked on the internet?
Look here: http://www.jvlai.com
This is my first comment here on this web site and I just wanted to say that I really enjoy the site and I visit it everyday. cheap shirt wholesale
great thing all of us gots the internet
Town and Country Planning in the UK
This extensively revised edition reinforces this title’s reputation as the bible of British planning. It provides an explanation of the nature of planning, the institutions and organizations involved, the plans and other tools used by planners, the system of controlling development and land use change and planning policies pursued.
The 14th edition has been thoroughly updated to reflect the many changes in town and country planning since the last edition. A review is given of the wide ranging changes to the planning system, the nature of plans, and the fuller amount of public participation in the planning process. Major changes have been made to the transport chapter, while there have been updates to heritage planning; the countryside; and the new provisions for devolved and regional government. A major addition deals with social inclusion (and its opposite – social exclusion). A widened discussion of housing policy and land availability draws upon the Cabinet Office study of housing land availability and land prices. Bibliographies and lists of official publications have also been updated.
Download Ebook Town and Country Planning in the UK
Good blog, but it would be better if in future you can share more about this subject. posts. http://www.howtotalmashah.com/electronics/video-promotion-best-practices-guidelines/
I was looking in google for something else, but I have to say your website is really interesting
What do you think of the recent defeat of the DREAM act? Is it impacting your projections for the future?
Economic Doctrine and Method
‘The translation of these essays is a testimony to Professor Schumpeter’s power in the analysis of economic thinking’ The Financial Times. This classic book is divided into four sections. The first gives a broad survey of economic thought from the days of Aristotle to the beginnings of modern times, and the second traces the development of the conception of the circular flow of economic forces. The third and fourth sections cover the main theorems of the classical economists and describe the genesis of the school of marginal utility.
Download Ebook Economic Doctrine and Method
The steadiness of your ideas are placed well considering the complexity of the topic. I can not begin to thank you enough for all you have done. Thank you for investing the time into this.
• You can also fax your subscription to the toll free number or can ask doctor to fax the prescription given by him that is based on your medical profile.
Good article, thanks. Can you tell us about the third paragraph more? http://www.breadmachinesreview.net/bread-machines/breadman-bread-machines
I’ll gear this review to 2 types of people: current Zune owners who are considering an upgrade, and people trying to decide between a Zune and an iPod. (There are other players worth considering out there, like the Sony Walkman X, but I hope this gives you enough info to make an informed decision of the Zune vs players other than the iPod line as well.)
Unions make up the spine of this nation. There may not be many workers remaining, however they fight with regard to workers’ rights. These rights, then, are translated over to additional non-union jobs. With out unions, we are all just individual employees attempting to battle for our privileges.
Some of the featured products that are offered by 24×7 pharmacies, foreign online pharmacy company include Acomplia drug which is an anorectic anti obesity drug and its major avenue of cause is reduction of appetite. Propecia is another drug that helps in re-growth of hair and prevents testosterone to be converted into DHT. You can view prescriptions on their website by simply searching the category and then by obtaining knowledge about that particular medication you can easily order that drug online.
• First step is to choose the medications and for this you must search the prices as well as the quantities that you would like to purchase that are available on the website. Click on “add to cart” in order to select the medicine that is stated in your prescription. Once you are through with the list click on secure checkout and check whether each and every medicine you require is being added to the cart or not.
Wow!, this was a top quality post. In theory I’d like to write like this too – taking time and real effort to make a good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate a lot and never seem to get something done.
By using online services a customer can refill or fill all the medical prescriptions while sitting at home and can order for the things that they wish to purchase. There are three simple steps that you would have to follow while ordering the prescription medications online from foreign online pharmacies, which is as follows:http://www.offshoremedicinepharmacy.com
Hey GreatBlog, is this the typical blog layout for this site?
This was a great article that really was really helpful to me and I really cant wait to learn more from your valuable experience. This was really very interesting to me. Thanks
I uncover your content very very good, though the search structure may be a bit far better organized.
Maybe now Martin Sheen has been fired from Two And A Half Men they should get the noticeably smaller Michael Fox in to replace him… and just call the show Two Men
Long time lurker. Just wanted to let you know that your side bar is broken.
Excellent post. I was checking continuously this blog and I’m impressed! Extremely helpful info specially the last part
I care for such information much. I was looking for this certain info for a long time. Thank you and best of luck.
Video chat has now taken on-line dating towards the following level and definitely created it a secure choice for the regional club or bar scene.